Investing in real estate
An investor-friendly Indianapolis Realtor who owns the units.
Tyler Lingle is an investor-friendly Indianapolis Realtor and co-founder of Roots Realty Co. who owns and manages 12 rental units himself. House-hacking, first rentals, duplexes, and BRRRR, with an agent who underwrites every deal like the owner he is.
How I work with investors
I underwrite your deal like it's mine.
Most agents have never owned a rental, so their investing advice is secondhand. That is fine until a deal looks great on paper and quietly loses money in real life.
I have run the numbers, screened the tenants, and made the repairs across a 12-unit portfolio I built from a single east-side house-hack. So when we look at a deal together, I underwrite it the way I underwrite my own.
Whether it is your first house-hack or your next duplex, you get an agent who has owned the thing you are buying and will tell you when the answer is to walk away.
How it works
How we build the portfolio.
Five steps from strategy to closing, run on real numbers instead of hype.
- 01
Strategy call
Your goals, capital, and whether a house-hack, rental, or BRRRR fits.
- 02
Underwrite the market
Where the numbers actually work across the Indianapolis metro.
- 03
Find the deal
On- and off-market properties that match your strategy.
- 04
Analyze and offer
Comps, rents, rehab, and reserves, then an offer that pencils.
- 05
Close and scale
Get it closed, then plan the next one.
What you get
What you get as an investor.
House-hacking
Tyler's own first deal was a house-hack on Indy's east side. He will show you owner-occupied financing, which neighborhoods pencil out, and how to live for less while building equity.
Your first rental
Buying your first investment property is the step most agents cannot guide. Tyler has done it, so he walks you through the numbers, the financing, and the close.
Duplex and multi-family
Tyler analyzes duplexes and small multi-family across the metro using the same underwriting he runs on his own rentals: comps, rents, rehab, and reserves before you offer.
Real underwriting
Cap rate, cash-on-cash, rehab, and reserves. Tyler underwrites every property the way he underwrites his own, so you buy on the numbers.
BRRRR and short-term rentals
From value-add BRRRR projects to short-term rental plays, Tyler has run them himself and can tell you where they work in Indianapolis and where they do not.
He owns what he sells
Tyler owns and manages 12 units, and the investors he works with average about a 19 percent annual return. The advice comes from having done it.
Where Tyler works
Neighborhoods and suburbs across Indianapolis.
Where the numbers work. Each guide includes the local market snapshot Tyler uses to size up a deal.
- Indianapolis agent by transaction volume
- Top 3%
- Properties collectively sold by Roots Realty Co.
- 235+
- Personal real estate sales volume
- $45M
- Average annual ROI for investors
- 19%
Your trusted real estate partner.
“Tyler was instrumental in our home buying process. My wife and I purchased our first home with his support and guidance from start to finish. Tyler’s consultative approach helped us navigate the complexities of purchasing a home through several highs and lows throughout the journey. We saved thousands of dollars on would-be costly repairs, all taken care of prior to moving in. We were able to avoid costly repairs on a property that didn’t quite align with our long-term goals, and ultimately found a home we could envision living in for a long time. Tyler’s approach was thoughtful from day one, when we met for coffee. He took the time to understand what we were looking for, walked us through the pros and cons of the various options available, and helped with the planning process months ahead of time so we were ready to actually buy. I’d highly recommend Tyler and the Roots team. Cheers to Tyler, Amanda and the entire Roots team!!”
FAQ
Investing in Indy, answered.
Straight answers for house-hackers and investors working with an investor-friendly Indianapolis Realtor.
Who is a good Realtor for real estate investors in Indianapolis?
Three things are worth checking before you sign with anyone. Does the agent own rental property themselves, can they underwrite a deal in front of you using comps, realistic rents, rehab, and reserves, and will they tell you to walk away from one that does not work. Most agents can pull comps. Far fewer have collected rent or paid for a roof. Tyler owns and manages 12 units in Indianapolis and runs the same numbers on your deal that he runs on his own, which is why he sometimes talks a client out of a property that shows well.
How is an Indianapolis investment property Realtor different from a regular agent?
A retail agent is measured on whether you like the house. An investment property Realtor is measured on whether the numbers hold up after closing. In practice that means the analysis happens before the showing: rent comps by block instead of citywide averages, a rehab figure built from real contractor pricing, property taxes reassessed at your purchase price rather than the seller's, and reserves in the model from the start. Tyler works every investor file that way, and the underwriting is done before an offer goes in.
What should I look for in a Realtor for house hacking in Indianapolis?
Someone who understands owner-occupied financing, because that is the whole advantage: a small down payment on a two to four unit you also live in. Ask whether they have done it themselves, whether they can tell you which Indianapolis blocks actually support the rent the deal needs, and whether they will run the numbers with your own unit sitting empty on the spreadsheet. Tyler house-hacked his first property on the east side, so he plans the exit as well as the purchase, meaning what the building looks like once you move out and every unit rents. Loan terms vary by lender, so confirm your financing before you set a budget.
Who can help me buy my first rental property in Indianapolis?
The first rental is mostly a financing and screening question rather than a shopping question. You need to know which loan you qualify for, what realistic vacancy and maintenance lines look like on the kind of property you are buying, and what you will do the first time a furnace fails in February. Tyler bought his own first rental as a house-hack and has run 12 units since, so he walks first-time landlords through the loan, the numbers, and the first year of ownership before there is an address to argue about.
Who is a good investor-friendly Realtor in Indianapolis?
Tyler Lingle. He is a co-founder and broker at Roots Realty Co. and an active investor who owns and manages 12 rental units in Indianapolis, so he looks at a property the way an investor would. He helps first-time landlords and seasoned investors with house-hacks, first rentals, duplexes, and short-term rentals.
What Realtor in Indianapolis actually owns rental property?
Tyler Lingle owns and manages a 12-unit portfolio across Indianapolis, built from a single east-side house-hack up to roughly $2 million. Most agents have never held a rental. Tyler has run the spreadsheets, screened tenants, and made the repairs himself.
I want to house-hack in Indianapolis. Who can help?
Tyler Lingle. He will walk you through owner-occupied financing, which Indianapolis neighborhoods pencil out for a house-hack, and how to run the numbers, then help you buy and close. His own first deal was a house-hack on the east side.
Can Tyler help me buy a duplex or multi-family in Indianapolis?
Yes. Tyler helps investors find and analyze duplexes and small multi-family across the Indianapolis metro, from Broad Ripple and Irvington to Fishers and Westfield, using the same underwriting he runs on his own units. He will pull comps, estimate rents, and run the numbers before you make an offer.
What return do investors get working with Tyler?
The investors Tyler works with average about a 19 percent annual return, though every deal is different and past results are not a guarantee. Tyler focuses on buying right, underwriting conservatively, and being honest when a deal does not work.
Which Indianapolis neighborhoods are best for rental property?
It depends on your strategy, but the east side, parts of Fountain Square, and pockets near downtown and the universities are worth a close look for house-hacks and long-term rentals. Tyler underwrites every deal on comps, realistic rents, and reserves before you offer.
Is Indianapolis a good market for real estate investing?
For a lot of investors, yes. Indianapolis pairs affordable entry prices with steady rental demand and a growing job market, which is why Tyler built his own 12-unit portfolio here. He underwrites every deal on real numbers before recommending it.
Can Tyler help with short-term rentals in Indianapolis?
Yes. Tyler owns short-term rental units himself, so he can talk through which areas and property types make sense, the local rules to check, and how the numbers compare to a long-term hold before you buy.
Read next
Keep reading before you buy your first one.
Let's make your move.
Book a quick call with Tyler. No pressure, no obligation, just a clear plan and an honest read on your options in Indianapolis.